Reading note / 02
What can you learn
before starting a study?
A careful review of existing material can reveal useful facts, conflicting accounts, and the questions that still need direct investigation.
Begin with material close to the question
Suppose you want to understand how an instruction is currently used. Existing manuals, support messages, and earlier revisions may be more relevant than a broad search for general advice. Start with material that describes the actual task and keep a note of where it came from.
Different sources answer different questions. A supplier document may explain an intended feature. A record of a user's difficulty may reveal how the feature behaved in one situation. Neither should automatically be treated as a complete account of ordinary use.
Record the conditions behind a claim
When a source reports that something worked, look for what was tested, how it was assessed, and when the work took place. A result from a narrow demonstration may not apply to another setting. Missing context is a reason to limit the conclusion, rather than supply the missing detail yourself.
Keep the source date and version alongside your notes. A current page may describe a changed product, while an older document may explain the version actually being considered. Recency helps, but relevance to the question matters too.
Separate the source from your interpretation
Use two short notes: what the material actually says, and what you think it might mean for the question. This helps prevent an inference from becoming an apparently established fact when the notes are shared with someone else.
If two sources disagree, preserve both accounts and the difference between their conditions. The disagreement may point to a useful follow-up question. It does not always mean one source must be discarded immediately.
Finish with a specific information gap
A useful review ends with a short statement of what is known, what is uncertain, and which uncertainty matters next. For the instruction example, the next question might concern one step that no existing record explains. That is a more concrete starting point than collecting an ever larger folder of reading.